Who’d’a thunk it? (Uncovering the origin of the Thinker)

[The Thinker]After almost 1½ years, my Golden-Age back-issue hunt finally netted a relatively cheap copy of All-Flash #12, the first appearance of the Flash villain, the Thinker. It’s an odd read, because the origin of the Thinker (a mob boss who plans his heists very meticulously) is interwoven with a slapstick story of the Three Dimwits.

All-Flash #12 (Fall 1943)The Thinker story is played more or less as a straight super-hero vs. organized crime story. I’d summarize it, but the Comics Archive has already written it up in their article on the Thinker. Now, imagine the first five paragraphs over there interwoven with a Three Stooges film and you’ll get the idea. The Dimwits end up buying a restaurant heavily in debt to the mob, and accidentally make salads out of an alien plant that make people turn invisible.

It’s incredibly silly, but it ties into the other half of the story: The original mob boss’ henchmen are caught robbing the Dimwits’ restaurant, so he calls in the Thinker to solve his problem before they can rat on him. And of course, once the Thinker takes over, he’s mighty interested in these salads that turn people invisible.

And yet, the feel is so completely different that it seems like two different stories.

The Three Dimwits

An unexpected discovery was a reference to the planet Karma, where the alien plant comes from. I’d seen two other references in other Golden-Age Flash stories, so it’s clearly part of the background mythos. This is one reason I’ve been looking for the source material. It’s relatively easy to find info on the leads, or the major villains, but the minor supporting characters who appear in three or four issues—Deuces Wilde, Evart Keenan, Dr. Flura, Ebenezer Jones—are mostly forgotten.

On a related note, while looking up the Thinker’s other appearances, I discovered that one of the non-Flash titles I’d been looking for, All-Star Comics #37, was reprinted in The Greatest Golden-Age Stories Ever Told—a book I already had. I felt bad that I hadn’t actually read the entire book, but that meant I could cross off two items from my wantlist instead of just one.

6 thoughts on “Who’d’a thunk it? (Uncovering the origin of the Thinker)

  1. Kelson Post author

    Yeah, the Thinker was the closest thing Jay Garrick had to an arch-enemy (since the Golden Age series made very little use of recurring villains). He appeared six times from 1943-1948, plus one more story that would have appeared in 1949 if the series hadn’t been canceled. It was eventually printed as a backup story in 1972.

    With so much of the early Flash stuff out of print, he’s mainly known these days as part of the trio from “Flash of Two Worlds” (Flash v.1 #123), the first meeting of Jay Garrick and Barry Allen. He teamed up with the Fiddler and the Shade in that story to terrorize Keystone City.

    He still shows up from time to time, most recently in the new Checkmate (as someone pointed out to me yesterday).

    Reply
  2. Kelson Post author

    Update on Karma: I determined that it first appeared in the previous issue. Amazingly enough, I found a reasonably-priced copy of All-Flash #11 fast enough that it barely had time to register on my want list.

    It took me three sittings to get through the story (it’s even more heavily focused on Winky, Blinky and Noddy), but I’ve finally posted a full write-up on the planet Karma.

    Reply
  3. Pingback: The Mechanical Brain « Speed Force

  4. Pingback: Wait…What? (Golden-Age Hijinks) « Speed Force

  5. Pingback: The Dimwits and the Thinker « Speed Force

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>